Lucy - But Grandmother! What Big Feet You Have

Mom, look at those tiny dolphins. A little girl had just left the dolphinarium and was staring at small tropical fish in an aquarium. Having looked at dolphins for the past hour or so she naturally assumed that the small creatures that were swimming around in the water were also dolphins.

Very often our presuppositions determine what we think we see. As adults, our presuppositions are often based on our worldview. Thus, throughout the world natural history museums present our supposed foremother Lucy (a species known as Australopithecus afarensis) as having big feet although the toe bones have never been found and Lucy's arms are clearly of the curved kind we associate with monkeys. They are well suited for hanging from trees but cannot be used for typing, for instance.

The National History Museum in London also presents Lucy as a roughly one meter (three feet) tall, big-footed ancestress of Homo sapiens. Why is this so? No one has found a better candidate and the famous Laetoli footprints of Tanzania are much larger than the typical small prints a monkey would leave. But they have been dated appoximately as old (about 3.2 million years) as Lucy.

We should perhaps congratulate the evolutionists for their brilliant logic: since the representatives of the Homo family had not yet evolved and since the footprints show without a shadow of doubt that three creatures walked on two feet some three million years ago, Lucy must have had big feet.

Radiometric dating methods are supposed to be reliable but few non-geologists are aware of the assumptions that lie behind each method. The methods are reliable only if three conditions are met:

1 Nothing except radioactive decay has altered the amount of parent isotopes (the original radioactive elements) and daughter isotopes (elements produced by the radioactive decay of other elements).

2 When the rock was formed, it contained a known amount of daughter isotopes (assumed to be zero).

3 The decay rate has always been constant.

Scientists can actually never be sure of any of these conditions. Professor Marvin Lubenow gives an interesting insight into the reliability of dating methods in his book Bones of Contention. In 1969 Richard Leakey discovered the skull known as KNM-ER 1470 (KNM stands for Kenya National Museum, where it is displayed, ER is East Rudolf, the region where it was found, and 1470 is the museum's acqusition number). The skull has many similarities with modern man but it was dated at 2.9 million years. The find was fiercely debated in the prestigious journal Nature for ten years, during which its age decreased by a million years.

Could it be possible that presuppositions have led us astray in Lucy's case, also? We might need a little girl to say, But Grandmother! What big feet you have. And perhaps the girl might also wonder why Grandmother looks much younger that she should.

Joel Kontinen is a translator and novelist currently living in Finland. His background includes an MA in translation studies and a BA in Bible and Theology. He likes to keep up-to-date on science news and often comments on creation/evolution and origins issues.

Blog: http://joelkontinen.blogspot.com/

E2macpets
Tortoise Supplies
Pet Reptile Supplies
Frog Toad Supplies
Pet Reptile Supplies
Apple News
Cell Phone News
#respond
Feed
Other
Nokia+n78
Nokia Cell Phones
Best New Cell Phones
Best New Cell Phones
Motorola+q9
Nokia News
#respond
Nokia
Hello World
Privacy Policy
#respond
Wholesale Lots
Buy
Nokia News Week June
Cell Phone And Pda Accessories
Pdas And Pocket Pcs
Motorola
#respond
Sitemap
Phone And Sim Cards
Motorola News
Cell Phones And Smartphones
Apple
Iphone News Week June
Iphone
#respond
Cell Phone
Apple Iphone
Iphone 20
Cell Phones
News
Generation Iphone Released
Second Generation Iphone
Motorola News Week June
Motorola Cell Phones
Bluetooth Accessories
Iphone
Types Of Pet Snakes The 4 Best Snakes To Keep As Pets
Other Geckos In Comparison With The Leopard Gecko
Pet Supply
Privacy Policy
Secret Tips For Scoring High On Science Fair Projects
Find Exotic Pets Online
#respond
How To Feed Your Bearded Dragon Lizard
Cage Decorations
Ten Things You Should Know About Pet Lizards
Tips On Buying An Amphibian For A Pet
Rat Intelligence Why Rats Are The Smartest Pets Out There
Petreptilesupplies
How To Bath A Bearded Dragon
#respond
Water Analysis In The Petroleum Industry A Useful Instrument
#respond
Bearded Dragon Food
Pet Care
#respond
Petreptilesupplies
Sitemap
#respond
Finding Mealworms Sale Tough
#respond
2
#respond
#respond
Feed
Bearded Dragon Books
Science Project Ideas 7 Kids Friendly Ideas
Other
#respond
Exotic Pet Insurance For Your Not So Common Pet
Enriching Your Lizards Life
Leopard Gecko Food
About Lizards The Leopard Gecko As A Pet
Leopard Gecko Books
New Telescope May Help Unlock The Mysteries Of Dark Energy
Supplies
#respond
H
Cure An Aggressive Pet Rat
Heaters
Characteristics Of Mammals
Reptiles
Reptile Cages
Alli
Sitemap
Xenadrine
Diet Pill Online
Adipex
Contact
Lipodrene
Lipovox
Phentermine
Ephedra
Phentramine
Ephedrine
Stimerex
Hoodia
Linzhi
Fastin
Ma Huang
Privacy Policy
Hydroxycut
E2macpets
Ball Python Supplies